Tuesday, April 10, 2007

Personal Narrative: First Draft

How do you define home? Some would say it’s “where the heart is”, still others would say it’s wherever you pay the rent. Maybe it’s a combination of both. In any case, I can answer that question quite easily. I have spent my entire life in Michigan, and am rooted there for good like the white pine the state calls its official tree.

Here’s a question that may be a bit more difficult to answer: How do you choose where “home” will be? It’s easy for people that get sent to work in a certain city; they don’t have a choice. As a graduate school applicant, I didn’t have this luxury. I had to choose where I would call home for the next five or more years of my life.

When I started to apply, I spent hours researching possible schools. I was meticulous and deliberate about my choices. Two top-ranked schools, two mediocre, a fall back option. They all had to be in cool cities; I was not going to spend a good portion of my life in Iowa (sorry Iowans). At that point, I was confident about what I was doing. I thought for sure I wouldn’t get into either of the top-tier programs.

“I’ll probably just go to Indiana,” I told everyone.

As usual, everyone but me was right. I was accepted at every school I applied to.

Naturally, everyone told me I was lucky. I had options. I didn’t care about options. I wanted them to make the decision for me; to make my life a little easier. I couldn’t decide, because I wouldn’t be able to live with myself if I made the wrong decision.

Thankfully, I had had the chance to visit each university. I held out the hope that there could only be one “best fit” and that by visiting, I would discover which place that was. This should make things easier, right? Wrong.

First was a visit to Austin, Texas. I was blown away by the city and the university. Leave it to the first experience to brand a lasting impression onto the brain. Everything about the place was perfect.

“I don’t even need to visit the other schools; I know I’m going to UT,” I told everyone.

I was committed to more visits, though, and next up was Indianapolis, Indiana. I was blown away. Never would I have expected the faculty to be such a fun group. I knew if I went there, I would be in good hands.

The third time I didn’t have to travel far: Ann Arbor, Michigan. I was blown away (notice the repetition). Michigan seemed to have it all: cool faculty and cool students that were as much a part of the school as the school is part of Ann Arbor. As a scientist, the symbiotic relationship resonated perfectly with me.

“You’re going to go to Michigan, it’s where you belong,” everyone told me.

The remaining two visits were no different. Northwestern University and Chapel Hill, North Carolina were both as equally mind-blowing. In no way did I believe it possible that there could be five “best fit” schools, but I knew I could see myself succeeding at each university and enjoying the atmosphere of the location while doing it.

It was at this point when I started to panic. I had to make a decision by a certain deadline and I wasn’t entirely sure I could do it. I would lean toward one of the schools, and then begin to doubt myself. This was hard! I usually know exactly what to do and can defend my actions in the face of criticism. This was a completely different ballgame. In fact, I was on a completely different playing field.

The logical scientist in me then began to make a list. Chapel Hill and Austin had the advantage of good weather. Check. Michigan and Chapel Hill were ranked highest. Check. The faculty at Indianapolis was the most interesting. Check. Wait a minute! The faculty at Michigan, Chapel Hill, Austin, and Northwestern was just as cool. Scratch that. The list wasn’t helping anything.

As a last ditch effort, I grabbed an easy read (Janet Evanovich’s Full Speed) and did some soul-searching-like thinking. I thought about how I felt about what I knew. I thought about how I felt about what I experienced. I thought about how I felt. There was nothing meticulous or deliberate about it. For once, I threw logical out the door. This time, I wouldn’t be able to defend my action with anything rational, and I was okay with that. It was all based on, well, feelings.

As usual, everyone but me was right. They already knew Michigan is where I belonged. They already knew I fit in perfectly in the Running Capital of America. They already knew I bled maize and blue. They knew what it took me months to figure out.

After a couple hours of thinking, I finally realized what I had probably known all along. Thinking about home is never about the tangible. Home is a feeling. Home will be where it already is. Home has to be where it already is. I’m going to be a Wolverine.

4 comments:

ChelsPhels said...

Hi Jenny,
I’m posting my comments since I’ll be at Frelon instead of class.
I like you topic, I think it’s something that a lot of us are going through right now. I also liked the way you used your home base of Michigan as a base to work with. What I felt was missing from the piece was you, I felt like I was reading a college app essay instead of a personal essay. What I really wanted to know more about was why everyone else knew what you already didn’t and why you did not automatically think Michigan was the right place for you? I would also like to know more about why Michigan resonates so well with you, why do you want to stay here, what’s your personal connection to the place? You also make a reference to soul searching (I was very happy to see a Janet Evonavich ref, on a side note), that’s a really enticing element that as a reader I want to know more about, but you blow over it. Basically I don’t want to know about the other schools, I want to read more about the internal conflict you were so clearly dealing with, again I’m really drawn to the idea that everyone knew before you. I think it’s a really good first draft, but I think since it’s a topic a lot of people can relate to, you have to find that one aspect that made it unique to you, the internal struggles you faced, that’s a lot more interesting than the pro’s and con’s different schools.
So those are my thoughts, sorry I had to miss workshop!

Dave Kelly said...

JT,

I really enjoyed reading your essay (even if I still will never like the school that you ended up choosing, but thats a whole other story ha). I thought you did a very good job of describing how difficult the decision was going to be for you, and of weighing all of the positives and negatives of each of the schools. You also did a great job of showing the urgency you felt in having to make a decision. I also thought that the way you used things repetively ("I was blown away" and how "everyone but me was right") really worked. The only thing I could say you may want to work on would be to go into more detail about what drew you to stay in Michigan or how you have always been a Wolverine your whole life.

Anonymous said...

Michigan is the place to be! I will be going there for grad school as well. SO it's nice to know that another K person will be around....as for your essay, I found it very engaging, and I actually didn't stop reading it until I got to the end. I would agree with Chelsea with the comment that I just wanted to know more about the internal conflict you were dealing with, and how you are a different person now after making the decision to attend Michigan.

Aaron said...

Hi Jenny,

First off, congrats. That's freakin' awesome.

If you knew Michigan was right for you all along, why didn't you just accept there off the bat and spare criss-crossing the country?

Ok, here's my real question, could you have known that Michigan was the right place for you if you hadn't visited all those places? What did you learn from visiting different universities?

So the big decision here is where you are going to spend the next five years of your life. I think the scientific process you introduce here; "The logical scientist in me then began to make a list..." could be a good vehicle to take the reader through how you made that choice.

You also list some criteria: weather, faculty, city coolness, but is that all you looked at? I think there is more there. What makes a mind-blowing school? I need to know that know why your mind was constantly blown.

But really, what I want to know, if what was different about this decision, where you are going to spend five year, than when you decided where you would spend four? Walk me through the Kalamazoo decision process in a paragraph. Certainly the coolness of the city or the weather played a factor.

The last sentence of your lede is good and a theme I think can appear toward the bottom of your essay. Consider chopping the question part of lede off and beginning with the white pine. Why did you choose that?

It goes back to what Chelsea said, there needs to be more you in the essay. I hope these questions gave you some avenues to explore.

Let me know if you have any other questions. I kind like this part of the process.

Aaron (http://specialaups.blogspot.com)